Second Sunday of Lent
Today’s Invitation
Today, we invite you to explore Paul as an organizer against empire; engage Catholic Social Teaching through base communities and liberation theology; and embody anti-empire organizing with the help of the Black Panthers, Fred Hampton, and the poetry of adrienne maree brown.
Second Sunday of Lent
Reading 1
Then YHWH tested Abraham.
“Abraham!” God called.
“Here I am,” Abraham replied.
“Take your son,” YHWH said,
“your only child Isaac, whom you love,
and go to the land of Moriah, ‘Seeing.’
Offer him there as a burnt offering, on a mountain I will point out to you.”
When they arrived at the place YHWH had pointed out,
Abraham built an altar there, and arranged wood on it.
Then he tied up his son Isaac and put him on the altar on top of the wood.
Abraham stretched out his hand and seized the knife to kill the child.
But the angel of YHWH called to him from heaven: “Abraham! Abraham!”
“Here I am!” he replied.
“Do not raise your hand against the boy!” the angel said.
“Do not do the least thing to him.
I know now how deeply you revere YHWH,
since you did not refuse me your son, your only child.”
Then looking up, Abraham saw a ram caught by its horns in a bush.
He went and took the ram, and offered it up as a burnt offering instead of his child.
The angel of YHWH called Abraham a second time from heaven, and said,
“I swear by myself — it is YHWH who speaks —
because you have done this, because you have not refused me your son, your only child,
I will shower blessings on you;
I will make your descendants as many as the stars of heaven and the grains of sand on the seashore.
Your descendants will possess the gates of their enemies,
and in your descendants all the nations of the earth will find blessing
— all this because you obeyed my command.”
Responsorial Psalm
Response: I walk before You, O God, in the land of the living.
I have faith even when I say, / “I am completely crushed.”
Precious in Your eyes / is the death of Your faithful.
R: I walk before You, O God, in the land of the living.
O God, I am Your servant, / Your servant, born of a pious family, You have freed me from my bonds.
I will offer You the thanksgiving sacrifice, / invoking Your name, O God.
R: I walk before You, O God, in the land of the living.
I will fulfill what I vowed to You / in the presence of all the people,
In the courts of the house of Our God, / in your midst, Jerusalem.
R: I walk before You, O God, in the land of the living.
Reading 2
If God is for us, who can be against us?
Since God did not spare the Only Begotten,
but gave Christ up for the sake of us all,
we may be certain, after such a gift, that God will freely give us everything.
Who will bring a charge against God’s chosen ones?
Since God is the One who justifies, who has the power to condemn?
Only Christ Jesus, who died — or rather, was raised —
and sits at the right hand of God, and who now intercedes for us!
Gospel
Jesus took Peter and James and John
and led them up a high mountain where they could be alone.
And there Jesus was transfigured before their eyes;
the clothes Jesus wore became dazzlingly white
— whiter than any earthly bleach could make them.
Elijah appeared to them, as did Moses,
and the two were talking with Jesus.
Then Peter spoke to Jesus.
“Rabbi,” he said, “how wonderful it is for us to be here!
Let us make three shelters — one for you, one for Moses and one for Elijah.”
Peter did not know what he was saying, so overcome were they all with awe.
Then a cloud formed, overshadowing them;
and there came a voice from out of the cloud:
“This my Beloved, my Own; listen to this One.”
Then suddenly, when they looked around,
they saw no one with them anymore — only Jesus.
As they were coming down from the mountain,
Jesus gave them orders not to tell anyone what they had seen
until after the Promised One had risen from the dead.
They agreed to this, though they discussed among themselves
what “rising from the dead” could mean.
The Inclusive Lectionary © 2022 FutureChurch. All rights reserved.
The inclusive language psalms:
Leach, Maureen, O.S.F. and Schreck, Nancy, O.S.F., Psalms Anew: A Non-sexist Edition
(Dubuque, IA: The Sisters of St. Francis, 1984).
Used with permission.
Explore
Reading Paul anew
I have come to understand Paul as one of our greatest Biblical resources for radical world-building. In my early twenties, a combination of healing my knee-jerk reaction to dismiss him, plus a few years of political organizing under my belt allowed me to hear his message in a new way. I saw a transformed person under the thumb of a deadly empire, trying to bring people together across lines of deep difference for the sake of Jesus’s mission of justice for all and lavish grace. In the place of a one-dimensional, homophobic misogynist, I saw a sharp organizer and profoundly radical disciple.
Dr. Theodore Jennings, a Methodist pastor and leftist theologian, contributed toward my understanding. In his book Outlaw Justice, he describes Paul’s mission as concerned not just with passing on religious teachings, but with introducing a new framework of how to construct society – a political philosophy, dealing with issues of common life.
Paul is writing to a church in a place where the structures of society and common life – “the law” that Paul references often in Romans – are ordered by a bloodthirsty empire. Referencing Jose Porfirio’s Marx and the Bible, Jennings writes, “Paul is read as offering a fundamental critique of Western civilization – a civilization that entails a political economy that impoverishes the masses while securing the privileges of the few” (7). Paul’s letters are a contrast to the mindset of this empire, written to the church to teach how society should be structured based on a Christ-centered politic, what Jennings calls “messianic political thinking.” This society is oriented around justice and God’s unconditional generosity, as opposed to values orienting Roman society, like subjugation and destruction.
The messianic political structure described across Paul’s letters stands in stark contrast to the political order of the day. He called for the crossing of boundaries – gender, economic, cultural – and the upending of hierarchical societal structures. They shared resources within the house churches and across the Mediterranean region, a radical redistribution of solidarity.
To live into this vision required praxis: real and tangible action undergirded by robust belief. And so throughout the epistles we see Paul giving practical steps as well as heartfelt encouragement. It’s problem-solving and vision-casting. To live in a radically different way, you must believe it is possible. We see some of this in today’s reading from Romans.
Of the opening line from Romans, Jennings writes, “Paul is writing to a tiny, embattled, and almost overwhelmed group, yet he asks, If God be for us, who is against us?” (137). I imagine it was easy to lose faith, to let the values of the world seep in. Paul reminds the church that a power greater than Rome is ordering their steps.
Paul asserts God’s willingness to act on behalf of God’s own – “He who did not spare his own son – how will he not also give us everything?” Jennings explains that this is not a statement about atonement, but generosity. God has given so much already – why would God stop now?
He continues and explains that those living under the messianic political worldview no longer need to find meaning in the political order of empire. If God acquits us, who will condemn? If we are set free by the messianic worldview, we cannot be condemned by the law. We are called to live in an entirely different paradigm.
This short excerpt is a snapshot into the instructions and encouragement of the book of Romans, building up the small, committed group to keep their heads up and carry on their mission in the face of a dominant culture that, at best, ran counter to their values and, at worst, sought to snuff them out.
For those of us working for justice today, we need this good word. On a daily basis, I need to reorient my heart to the reality that God is unquestionably for the work of justice. God is for us. How we get there is what we work out together in community, across lines of difference informed by those who went before and leaders in our own times, continuing the work of God’s messianic vision for the world.
Commentary by Grace Aheron
Engage Catholic Social Teaching
I’m not Catholic, but have been powerfully shaped by Catholic social teachings, which I encountered through liberation theology and the Catholic Worker.
The term “liberation theology” came about after Vatican II and Latin American lay people and priests’ concerns with how to respond to deep injustices in Latin America, birthing new theology and communities of practice, and fueling political revolutions across the region.
In reflecting on today’s scripture from Paul, we can see echoes of Paul’s house churches across the Mediterranean in the liberatory base communities in Latin America. “Base communities” were essentially house churches that put into practice liberation theology’s bottom-up orientation – the belief that scriptural interpretation should be put directly into the hands of the poor, the community with whom the Gospel is most at home. Sometimes with priests, but far more often without, base communities would read the mass together and study scripture.
What moves me most today about base communities and the early house churches, in light of a growing movement for authoritarian rule both here in the US and abroad, is their commitment to growth through organizing. So often in the progressive church world, I wonder if we have a fear of growth, and so instead we stay small, exclusively bringing in people whose worldviews already agree with our own. The impulse to have a small, local impact is, I fear, not enough to face down what we are up against.
Paul’s churches and base communities were organizing toward a purpose. And to achieve that purpose, they needed more people, more power. They were organizers. In Brazil, it’s estimated that by the early 2000s there were nearly 80,000 active base communities, nearly all lay-led. They came together to not only take care of the needs amongst them, but to organize to address issues in their community around healthcare and education.
These small church communities with grand missions invite us to be not only brave in the scale of impact, but practical in the implementation of our visions for change. To do justice is not about maintaining ideological purity, but it is messily reckoning with the realities of the current political structures we find ourselves in. Like the Romans, we find ourselves under a law that powers an empire of exploitation. And so like the base communities, we must find a way to come together to be bigger than the sum of our parts and commit to not just dreaming about, but winning the world so many of us so desperately need.
A Witness
The Black Panthers were another community of practice whose praxis sought to reshape society. They brought people into the movement around things people needed, and were their rights – food for children, education, basic living supplies – and then organized them. Like the early church and base communities, their work was rooted in an urgency and a desire for scale – that things needed to urgently change, and for a massive number of people.
Chairman Fred Hampton was the leader of the Black Panther Party in Chicago. He was murdered by the FBI once he started organizing across lines of race, bringing poor white people and Puerto Ricans and Black people together over their common struggles. This is the thing those in power fear the most and why they try so ardently to reify our belief in lives of division. There are more of us than there are of them. When we come together, we outnumber them. This was happening in the early church, in base communities, and in a multiracial coalition of poor people in Chicago.
Fred Hampton’s writing sounds a lot like Jesus. He writes that love for the people is at the core of everything he does.
Art
Writer and facilitator adrienne maree brown wrote the poem “loving people like fred hampton” as an ode to his commitment to love. In it, we hear what it takes to be changed for the sake of changing the world around you, and the requirement of committing to communal struggle for the sake of overcoming empire. https://adriennemareebrown.net/2017/12/05/loving-the-people/
“i’m going to live for the people
because i love the people”
– Fred Hampton
lately everything has been changing fast
and we are reminded, in case we forgot,
that our blood is sacred
that it might be required
for the spell, the strategy, the next move
we are called extremists for our love
of ourselves
of our people
of our humanity
it is not enough to articulate
a radical politic
we have to declare a warrior nature
we have to embody yes-to-the-mystery
for, knowing nothing about our deaths,
we must promise to give our lives
to the future
to the children
to strangers with our skin
and maybe it isn’t your last breath
that is most needed right now
but, for the people, would you change?
for the people, would you apologize? forgive?
for the people, would you be honest?
for the people, would you learn, and learn?
– not for me
not for you
but for all of us?
because if you refuse to change
to look within and seek yourself out
your freest self, and your systemic self
your self which is imperfect and must grow
your harmed self who causes harm
your heartbroken self, and your resilient self
how can i trust your blood
how can i trust your work
how can i trust your love?
we do not survive when we live for ourselves
when we die our truths are forgotten
held in no heart, at most a legend
part of no wholeness, tender in no memory
when we live for the people
we never die, seeded so deeply in each other
love yourself, and the people
give your life for the people
give yourself to the people