Eleventh Sunday of Ordinary Time
Today’s Invitation
Today we invite you to explore the parables of the sower and the mustard seed through an ecoliberationist lens; engage the history of English religious reformers who reclaimed common land for the people, according to the laws of Christianity; and embody the freedom and liberation of all beings with a reflection on “The Destruction of Palestine is the Destruction of the Earth” by Andreas Malm.
Eleventh Sunday of Ordinary Time
Reading 1
This what YHWH says: “I myself will take a shoot from the top of a cedar and
plant it on a lofty and high mountain. I will plant it on the mountain heights of Israel. It will grow branches, bear fruit and become a splendid cedar. All kinds of birds will nest in it. They will find shelter in the shade of its branches. All the trees of the countryside will know that I am YHWH who stunt tall trees and make low trees grow. I dry up the green tree and I make the dry tree flourish. I, YHWH have spoken, and I will do it.
Responsorial Psalm
Response: O God, it is good to give You thanks.
O God, it is good to give You thanks, / to sing psalms to Your Name, O Most High.
To declare Your love in the morning / and Your faithfulness every night
R: O God, it is good to give You thanks.
The just flourish like a palm tree, / they grow tall as a cedar of Lebanon.
Planted as they are in the house of the Creator,
They flourish in the courts of Our God.
R: O God, it is good to give You thanks.
Bearing fruit in old age like trees full of sap, / vigorous, wide-spreading.
Eager to declare that Our God is just, / my Rock,
Reading 2
And so we are always full of confidence, even though we realize that to live in the
body means to be absent from Jesus Christ. We walk by faith, not by sight. We are full of confidence, I repeat, and would actually prefer to be absent from the body and make our home with Christ. Whether we are living in the body or absent from it, we are intent on pleasing Christ. For we must all appear before the judgment seat of Christ, and each of us will get what we deserve for the things we do while in the body, good or bad.
Gospel
Jesus said further, “The reign of God is like this: a sower scatters seed on the ground, then goes to bed at night and gets up day after day. Through it all the seed sprouts and grows without the sower knowing how it happens. The soil produces a crop by itself — first the blade, then the ear, and finally the ripe wheat in the ear. When the
crop is ready, the sower wields the sickle, for the time is ripe for harvest.”
Jesus went on to say, “What comparison will we use for the reign of God? What image will help to present it? It is like a mustard seed that people plant in the soil: it is the smallest of all the earth’s seeds, yet once it is sown, it springs up to become the largest of shrubs, with branches big enough for the birds of the sky to build nests in its shade.”
Using many parables like these, Jesus spoke the message to them, as much as they could understand. Everything was spoken in parables, but Jesus explained everything to the disciples later when they were alone.
The Inclusive Lectionary © 2022 FutureChurch. All rights reserved.
The inclusive language psalms:
Leach, Maureen, O.S.F. and Schreck, Nancy, O.S.F., Psalms Anew: A Non-sexist Edition
(Dubuque, IA: The Sisters of St. Francis, 1984).
Used with permission.
Explore
Embodying Liberation and Freedom
The mustard bush is quite common in Palestine – now and when Jesus spoke the words of today’s parable. It is always worth noting in the parables how Jesus uses the language of everyday life to express principles for coming to understand who he is and the reign of God he is inviting us to live in. The brilliance of this parable is that the throughline to this parable is rather obvious to the listener or reader: we must have patience and faith that the smallest of actions, deeds, the most seemingly insignificant people, the marginalized, the oppressed, will grow from the soil without any of our doing. We must simply sow seeds. In the words of Jesus, “It [the reign of God] is like a mustard seed that people plant in the soil: it is the smallest of all the earth’s seeds, yet once it is sown, it springs up to become the largest of shrubs, with branches big enough for the birds of the sky to build nests in its shade.” In other words, the reign of God is provided by the wisdom of God in God’s creation. The reign of God, in which the captives are set free, the oppressed liberated, the lost saved, and the unwhole made complete, is simply following the wisdom of God made evident in Creation, and aligning ourselves as the sower who allow’s God wisdom to take root in our lives and liberate us all.
In the history of salvation and liberation, our human vocation is to be sowers and gardeners. While it is important for pedagogical purposes that Jesus is connecting with his peasant and agrarian audience with the image of a worker like themselves, there is also a lot more going on here. Beyond the direct connections Jesus is making to the prophets before him, in particular our reading from Ezekial, Jesus is also harkening back to the symbolic world and interpretive pattern of Genesis when he evokes the image of the sower and their relationship to soil. In An Ecological Theology of Liberation: Salvation and Political Ecology, Daniel P. Castillo establishes Genesis as a key for a political, ecological, and eco-liberationist biblical interpretation. For Castillo, to be created in God’s image, is to be created as a gardener who cares for, serves the needs of, and allows Creation to come into being. As all Creation, including humanity, is brought forth from the soil, humanity’s vocation is to help facilitate and participate in the process of Creation (71). This vocation is intrinsic to God’s intention for humanity – an intention made apparent in the naming of the first human “Adam,” or adamah (אדמה) in Hebrew meaning soil (74). Castillo writes:
“The intimacy of the relationship between the human and the soil is reinforced etymologically: God creates the human, ‘Adam’ (ādām), out of the earth (‘adāmâ). Here, then, both love of the earth and love of neighbor are constitutive of the vocation of the gardener. Moreover, since the love of the earth and neighbor are understood as the proper response to God’s call to the human, the love of God is also intrinsic to the vocation of gardener. The human person responds positively to God (thereby exhibiting a love of God) by cultivating and caring for the soil and all that comes from the soil… the love of God is expressed through the interrelated loves of neighbor and earth” (74).
Thus, for Castillo, the reign of God, expressed and embodied in Christ in the Gospels in the person of Jesus, is also expressed as the call to inhabit the image of God “through properly responding to God’s call to love the soil and all that comes from the soil, thereby enfleshing God’s wisdom in the world” (76).
In the Parable of the Mustard Seed, Jesus, in the pattern of Genesis so readily echoed throughout the Bible, is calling us back into a relationship with the soil in our vocation as gardeners. While there is no doubt that Christ himself is the sower planting seeds that will grow and become the Kingdom of God, and speaking in a note that will communicate spiritual truth to his audience, Jesus’s words should also be taken to be pointing toward a literal renewal of relationship with Creation that realizes the reign of God. In its salvific and liberatory reality, the reign of God not only includes humanity but all of Creation: the trees, plants, animals, the birds of the air, rivers, and oceans. Our vocation is not just to tend the garden, but to learn from and to co-articulate with Creation a liberation that includes every person and all created beings. As the sower plants seeds and patiently waits, as the mustard bush provides nests and shade for the birds, so too will our love of neighbor and earth free us all.
Commentary by Ryan Felder
Engage Catholic Social Teaching
As an applied theological framework for sowing seeds and reclaiming our vocation as gardeners, let’s briefly consider the eco-liberative, theological framework of 17th century religious reformer Gerrard Whinstanley. Winstanley was born in 1609 in Wigan, England. He was a tailor and freeman at Merchant Taylors Company before falling into poverty after the death of his father and the outbreak of war. Once the English Civil War started in 1640, Winstanley quickly came under the influence of political reformer John Lilburne and the associated Levellers, a movement of social populist reformers. This influence was short-lived, however. By 1649, Winstanley had stopped identifying with the Levellers and participated in forming the Diggers, an agrarian socialist movement, also known as the True Levellers.
During this period, Winstanley was both the most politically active and prolific in his writing – he wrote several pamphlets and treatises exhorting the ideology and strategy of the Diggers. More radical than the Levelers, the Diggers advocated for the direct re-taking of recently enclosed common land for egalitarian, communal use. As an act of defiance and prefigurative politics, the Diggers would re-take enclosed and idle land by digging up hedges, cultivating it, and begin communally sharing the work, harvest, and life together. This movement culminated in the re-taking of St. George’s Hill in 1650, where a commune of at least 100 Diggers formed and began cultivating the land for common use. Concomitantly, historians note that at least five other Digger-inspired communes formed within the year. All of the Digger communes were routed and crushed within the year by combinations of state, local landlord organizing, and mob violence.
Central to Whinstanely’s radicalism was a interpretation of the Bible that both informed and was formed by his revolutionary and eco-liberationist practice. Winstanley’s writings often expound an interpretation of the biblical text that connects history, political oppression, land, and a preferential option for the poor, such as what much of Latin American liberation theology espouses. As a primary example, in the Law of Freedom and Other Writings, he writes:
“O thou A-dam, thou Esau, thou Cain, thou hypocritical man of flesh, when wilt thou cease to kill thy younger brother? Surely thou must not do this great work of advancing the creation out of bondage; for thou art lost extremely, and drowned in the sea of covetousness, pride and hardness of heart. The blessing shall rise out of the dust which thou treadest underfoot, even the poor despised people, and they shall hold up salvation to this land and to all lands, and thou shalt be ashamed” (83).
In other words, whether or not the human family is in a state of freedom or oppression is inextricably linked to the land. Directly referring to humanity-as-interdependent-with-dirt, as A-dam, Winstanley understands the trajectory of Adam’s lineage to be one of conflict over the earth itself. Winstanley understood there to be a specific trajectory within human history in which the powerful (Cain, Ishmael, and Essau) rule by violence and the oppressed they rule over (Abel, Isaac, and Jacob) receive the oppressor’s birthright as a preferential option. In Winstanely’s context, the enclosure of common land in England was another form of this rule of Cain. In this line of reasoning, Winstanley condemns landlords as bearers of the mark of Cain. He writes:
“For the power of enclosing land and owning property was brought into the creation by your ancestors by the sword; which first did murder their fellow creatures, men, and after plunder or steal away their land, and left this land successively to you, their children. And therefore, though you did not kill or thieve, yet you hold that cursed thing in your hand by the power of the sword; and so you justify the wicked deeds of your fathers; and that sin of your fathers shall be visited upon the head of you and your children, to the third and fourth generation, and longer too, till your bloody and thieving power be rooted out of the land.”
The mark of Cain, for Winstanley, is the power derived by, and the resultant intergenerational trauma of, claiming for oneself what God gave in common to all of humanity. A consequence of this is the enslavement of those descendants of Abel: the dispossessed, the weak, and the oppressed. With the common gift of God claimed by Cain, the descendants of Abel are dispossessed, forced to wander, and work for Cain as a means of subsistence.
A Contemplative Exercise
In our current polycrisis of climate change, ascendant eco-fascist tendencies, and genocide, how should we orient ourselves as sowers of the reign of God? The ongoing genocide and ecocide in Palestine and Gaza is one of the most urgent and glaring examples in our own time of interrelated natures of colonialism, imperial domination, political domination, Christian nationalism, and the devastation of both Palestinian communities and their homeland. Professor of Human Ecology Andreas Malm in “The Destruction of Palestine Is the Destruction of the Earth” details the long, interlinked history of Western imperialism, the extractive fossil fuel economy, Zionism, and the genocide and ethnic cleansing of the Palestinian people.
We should and must understand the liberation of Palestine from the Zionist and U.S. imperialist entity as a necessary step in the history of salvation and the future of the liberation and freedom of all peoples and created beings. At stake is the very notion of what it means to be created in the image of God and the continued distortion of our relationship with the earth. According to Daniel P. Castillo, inherent in the Imago Dei, is an undercutting of any singular declaration that any one human organization is the right one. Castillo writes, “Just as no single ruler can define the right ordering of the world, no one culture or political regime can dictate, in a totalizing manner, the proper ways of relating to the earth” (71). Our vocation then is to sow the seeds of God’s freedom – whether they be mustard seeds or poppy seeds, to let those closest to the land teach us what it means to be responsive to God’s wisdom, and let the freedom and liberation of all Creation dictate the standards of how we show up in the world as Christians seeking the reign of God.