Accessibility Tools

Skip to main content

Twenty-Fourth Sunday of Ordinary Time

September 15, 2024

Today’s Invitation

Today we invite you to explore Jesus’s alternative to empire; engage the idea of ‘losing ourselves’ through the concept of the universal church; and embody solidarity with a contemplative exercise and the example of Aysenur Eygi.


Commentary by Ben Stegbauer and Tess GC

Twenty-Fourth Sunday of Ordinary Time


Reading 1

Isaiah 50:4-9

Exalted YHWH has given me
a skilled and well-trained tongue,
so that I can sustain the weary
with a timely word.
YHWH awakens me morning after morning —
wakens my ear, to listen like a student.
Exalted YHWH opened my ears
and I have obeyed,
I did not turn away.
I offered my back to those beating me,
offered my cheeks to those who would humiliate me.
I did not hide my face from insults
or spitting.
Because Exalted YHWH helps me,
insults cannot wound me,
for I have set my face like flint,
because I know I will not be put shame.
My vindicator is at my side.
Who would dare accuse me?
Let us confront each other!
Who are my adversaries?
Let them accuse me!
It is Exalted YHWH who helps me.
Who will judge me guilty?
All of them will wear out like a piece of clothing;
moths will devour them.

Responsorial Psalm

Psalm 116

Response: I walk before You, Adonai, in the land of the living.

I love You, Adonai, because You have heard / my voice and my supplications.
Because You have inclined Your ear to me, / therefore, I will call on You as long as I live.
R: I walk before You, Adonai, in the land of the living.

The cords of death encompassed me, / the pangs of Sheol laid hold on me;
I suffered sorrow and anguish. / Then I called on Your name, Adonai.
Oh Adonai, I beseech You, save my life!
R: I walk before You, Adonai, in the land of the living.

Gracious are You, Adonai, and righteous, / You are full of compassion.
You protect the simple-hearted; / when I was brought low, You saved me.
R: I walk before You, Adonai, in the land of the living.

For You, Adonai, have delivered my soul from death,
My eyes from tears, my feet from stumbling.
I walk before You, Adonai, / in the land of the living.
R: I walk before You, Adonai, in the land of the living.

Reading 2

James 2:14-18

My sisters and brothers, what good is it to profess faith without practicing it? Such faith has no power to save. If any are in need of clothes and have no food to live on, and one of you says to them, “Goodbye and good luck. Stay warm and be well-fed,” without giving them the bare necessities of life, then what good is this? So it is with faith. If good deeds do not go with it, faith is dead.

Some of you will say that you have faith, while I have deeds. Fine. I will prove to you that I have faith by showing you my good deeds. Now you prove to me that you have faith without any good deeds to show.

Gospel

Mark 8:27-35

Then Jesus and the disciples set out for the villages around Caesarea Philippi. On the way Jesus asked the disciples this question: “Who do people say that I am?”

They replied, “Some, John the Baptizer; others, Elijah; still others, one of the prophets.”

“And you,” he went on to ask, “who do you say that I am?”

Peter answered, “You are the Messiah!” But Jesus gave them strict orders not to tell anyone about him.

Then Jesus began to teach them that the Promised One had to suffer much, be rejected by the elders, chief priests and religious scholars, be put to death, and rise again three days later. Jesus said these things quite openly.

Peter then took him aside and began to take issue with him. At this Jesus turned around and, eyeing the disciples, reprimanded Peter: “Get out of my sight, you Satan! You are judging by human standards rather than by God’s!”

Jesus summoned the crowd and the disciples and said, “If you wish to come after me, you must deny your very self, take up your cross and follow in my footsteps. If you would save your life you will lose it, but if you lose your life for my sake, you will save it.”


The Inclusive Lectionary © 2022 FutureChurch. All rights reserved. 

The inclusive language psalms:
Leach, Maureen, O.S.F. and Schreck, Nancy, O.S.F., Psalms Anew: A Non-sexist Edition
(Dubuque, IA: The Sisters of St. Francis, 1984).
Used with permission.

Read

Explore

Losing Ourselves in the Universal Church


Late August and September have a strange feeling to them. The air is slower and sleepier than all summer before, but underneath you can feel the energy building – cool air to shock us out of the heat, the work of harvests and new school years and new beginnings just as the natural world enters its preparation for laying fallow. Each season has its own moment for assessing where we are at and where we are going, and today’s Gospel passage gives us that opportunity in this season. 

In today’s Gospel, we experience a Jesus who is always trying to direct people toward living in the way that makes a more beautiful and just world a reality. Jesus shows his way as the opposite of the rule of empire. Let us use this day to ask ourselves what that looks like in this season.

The first lines that stand out to me in this Gospel are Jesus’s question to the disciples, and his reaction to their response:

“Who do people say that I am?”

Peter answered, “You are the Messiah!”

But Jesus gave them strict orders not to tell

anyone about him.

When I was in divinity school, I remember discussing this passage in a Bible course. My professor, Dr. Brigitte Kahl, a scholar of the New Testament, explained Jesus’s reaction as the opposite of how the powerful of the Roman Empire conducted themselves. Caesar, Herod, and Pontius Pilate never lost an opportunity to proclaim and exert their dominance over others. In response to the rule of Rome, Jesus begins to think and act under a different set of rules. Throughout the Gospel of Mark, Jesus constantly asks the crowds who gather (Mark 3:7-12); the people he heals (Mark 1:40-5); and the disciples not to say anything about his supposed divinity. 

There are several possible reasons for his insistence: Trying to evade detection and retribution from the Romans; the possibility that Jesus himself did not claim to be divine at all; or an insistence that the work he was doing – the movement he was building – were not about him at all, but about teaching people to turn toward each other in the face of great oppression. All three of these possibilities could be true. I want to focus on the third possibility and how it connects to another standout line from today’s Gospel passage:

If you would save your life you will lose it, but

if you lose your life for my sake, you will

save it.

For many of us in our modern lives, we read this passage and wonder how much we ‘have to’ give up if we want to follow the path that Jesus lays out. There are many ways to lose your life – to actually die for the message of Jesus, which many of his disciples would go on to face; or to experience social losses, familial losses, sacrificing perhaps a career, money, a certain kind of life. The Christian world is full of people on each end of the spectrum, those giving up nothing, and in fact taking more than their share, and denying the goodness of life to other people; and those who have removed themselves from the everyday functioning of the society around them, living in poverty or degradation in the name of God, and thinking that others should do this as well. Perhaps Jesus’s call in this passage isn’t for one extreme or another, or even for something in the middle of each extreme. Perhaps Jesus is talking about a way of living that grounds us in our togetherness as people, and that respects each person, including ourselves. 

The entire Gospel today, when we view Jesus as a connector, a movement builder, shows a person who hopes to create a world that is the opposite of the Roman Empire they suffer under. We might call this world the kingdom of God. We might call it a people’s movement. It is a world of solidarity with one another’s difficulties, of seeing ourselves in the other and the other in ourselves, and a world in which what matters most isn’t Jesus’s exceptionalism, but the fact that he is one of us, he is with us, and he believed in this world we can build together, against the oppressive rulers of our time.

What I read here is that building the kingdom of God isn’t about denying ourselves all worldly pleasures, or removing ourselves from the world that is. It’s about living in the spirit and image of what we think a kingdom of God should look like. It often comes down to that little word, solidarity. When we live in solidarity with those around us, we will find that life according to the rule of empire and capitalism doesn’t usually give us wealth or prestige, and we will have to accept the loss of those things. But we will find that those things usually have to be lost in order to save our lives, and live into the things we know, deep down, matter most of all. The things that make life full and worth living. Solidarity means love, it means courage, it means caring for the self so that you can care for the other. If we choose the rule of the empire, we lose our connection to those things.

Commentary by Ben Stegbauer and Tess GC


Ben Stegbauer and Tess GC met in divinity school. Ben is a native of Cincinnati, Ohio, the greatest city in the world. He now lives in New York City at the Catholic Worker. Tess was born and raised in western Montana on Salish land, in an Irish American family. She thinks a lot about land, place, belonging, and labor.
Explore

Engage Catholic Social Teaching

Solidarity

By Ben Stegbauer

It may in fact be hard to write about this concept of giving ourselves over in solidarity to others. It is so foundational to the Christian message, and at times we could even use the word cliche. It is said so much that it begins to feel watered down. And yet at the same time perhaps we take it for granted too. 

I have been reflecting a lot about the concept of church recently, most especially the affective component of being church together. How does it feel to hold one another? How does it feel to be cared for by one another? How does it feel to have someone be in solidarity with you? 

Likewise, how does it feel to care for others? How does it feel to hold someone you care for? How does it feel to be in solidarity with others? In my experience it actually feels quite good. It feels like the aforementioned life-worth-living. 

I say this because as the world turns more and more toward dissolution and collapse, perhaps this is what we need to hold onto more than anything else. It is the solidarity, it is the holding, it is the caring for, by, and with one another that makes life worth living. It is being church to one another. And it is taking church as seriously as possible. Always trying to push holding, caring, and solidarity one step further. Maybe that is what it is all about. Being church to one another.

I am intrigued by how this feeling or effect seems to go both ways well. It is only with others that we are truly able to feel and grieve things as much as we want to be able to. How are we supposed to hold the depravity, the rage, and the grief of the world by ourselves? How are we supposed to hold the evil, the loss, and the mourning of genocide in Palestine and Congo by ourselves? Perhaps we can’t. We just simply can’t.

It seems throughout history that it is people coming to care and hold each other, this act Christianity and Catholicism would call being universal church to one another, that also allows us to hold the pain of the world and even the pain of our lives. To hold the grief of the loss of loved ones, of worsening living conditions, to help when the bills don’t add up, and classically to bring over a casserole after a birth or death. 

But also perhaps it is Church in this way that also gives us the capacity to change and transform within this grief. To accept the depths of loss and to lean into our new realities. To lean into the reality of a world built on multiple imperial genocides. To transform, within the indisputable reality of a place built on an economy of militarism. 

It takes so much effort to not lose ourselves within the great economy of empire. Within the swirling social relations we are forced to work in even when we find them gravely immoral. We simply cannot do it alone. It seems to me that Church is more important than ever. And it is a great sadness that years and years of capitalist alienation perhaps has made it more foreign than ever. We need each other in order to process the loss that is existing in contemporary America, in “the belly of the beast.” We need each other to transform each other in our grief and in our madness. We need each other to let loose these feelings of grief onto the world. To crush the imperial machine, weapons manufacturers, and to finally be able to take care of eachother. We need each other in order to lose ourselves, and thus be saved.

Engage

A Contemplative Exercise


I recently finished reading The Golden Gulag by Ruth Wilson Gilmore, and in the conclusion there is a paragraph that floored me. I wish I had read this book years ago. Maybe even as a third grader, just because it seems so foundational. (Also to say this paragraph is being taken out of context, but it still is telling for what I want to contemplate on.) 

“The bottom line is this: if the twentieth century was the age of genocide on a planetary scale, then in order to avoid repeating history, we ought to prioritize coming to grips with dehumanization. Dehumanization names the deliberate, as well as the mob-frenzied, ideological displacements central to any group’s ability to annihilate another in the name of territory, wealth, ethnicity, religion. Dehumanization is also a necessary factor in the acceptance that millions of people (sometimes including oneself) should spend part or all of their lives in cages” (243).

I could not help but think of the readings when I read this. Losing oneself. Losing one’s humanity. Dehumanization. I want to contemplate on this fact of the dehumanization in the world. Of Palestinians by the ideology of Zionism. By Congolese by the ideology of capitalist extraction and racism. By Haitians in Springfield Ohio by xenophobia, racism, and fear mongering propaganda. 

Perhaps we need to reflect and contemplate on the context in which we live. Sit with the gravity that dehumanization is. How we see loved ones around us losing themselves to this, because of hatred growing in their bodies. How we see other loved ones have their humanity ripped from them. How we have lost ourselves to the dehumanization of others. How we have been dehumanized.

How best can we align ourselves as the dehumanized, with those that have had their humanity ripped from them? How can we resist being lost? How can we resist the loss that is genocide? How can we refuse to lose?

A Witness

Aysenur Eygi

Aysenur Eygi was killed last week in the West Bank protesting new and illegal Israeli settlements. She was a Turkish American who had just recently graduated from the University of Washington, and apparently had participated in campus protests there as well. Her community describes her as someone with a deep and fierce sense of international solidarity. Within her was held the world. In the West Bank, the Palestinian people held a funeral service for her. The lives lost seem an unimaginable number to mour,n and the courage of the Palestinians and those like Eygi seems too large to honor. 


Embody